Comments: 17
Skybase [2010-07-20 04:06:22 +0000 UTC]
Very nice. Stylish, dark, and a wonderful use of stock material.
But of course, room for improvement is available:
We first off start with the clouds. To me, they kinda look out of proportion, as in they look stretched / distorted which gives an uneasy feel when looking at it. May need some cutting, brushing, and otherwise to fix the issue.
The other thing is lighting. This is key and I'm very picky on it. The overall lighting direction is ok, I can forgive that, but what bothers me is the contrast ratio between the clouds and the sea. The sea is basically too bright and doesn't do what seas actually do when they go to the horizon. The thing is, when you view the ocean down to its horizon, you'll see that it doesn't simply go plop, but fade. Now it's not always the case, but in this picture, I expect it to fade gently to black or gray or whatever color suggests the depth. I would suggest using a gradient overlay to slowly draw our attention to the sky beyond just on the sea, and while leaving some detail behind, it should be ok.
The lighting on the female figure is also overly dim and has a funny black fuzz around it. This can be fixed by cleaning up/masking layers. While being the subject of the piece, my eye is easily drawn to the details of the ripples of the sea and so on. Again, lighting here is an issue. We have the dimmed light coming from the left side, and the light indeed follows, but fails when we get to the cloth she's sitting on. The cloth seems to catch a different light source, where we don't see any of it. Be warned of those next time.
Conclusions:
Be keen with lighting. It's one of the most important things that make your work look at its best. But we must be careful. It's also the biggest that makes a piece of art sink. About 90% of the works I critique have issues with lighting. We see things that defy logic and the flow of the work when lighting goes bad. However, I must say that this is well done. Please continue. Have fun.
- Skybase
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
M3-Productions [2010-07-19 00:25:47 +0000 UTC]
Nicely done, thank you for using our stock.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
whutnot [2010-07-17 00:01:16 +0000 UTC]
very lovely and it fits the song very well!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1