Comments: 41
CerberusReigns [2010-05-15 00:22:27 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
Hey there!
Haven't critiqued in a while, so I hope this is okay.
Firstly, the background. The colors are amazing! They really work to add a more dramatic feel to the picture. And despite the contrast of the colours of the sky and the water, they actually look pretty good together. The reflection on the lake is really well done too.
The texture on the trees and leaves is brilliant! It's one of my favourite parts of the piece.
It's great how you add the shadows of the leaves on the grass and on the cats too!
All I can suggest for the background is to add some more detail to the sand, it looks too flat. The roots of the trees also stand out. Maybe you could try blending them into the grass a little?
Onto the cats:
Hawkfrost's expression is perfect. Suprised and fearful. The character design is cool too! Complex, but amazing. The two front paws are really good, but the two back paws look a little odd, especially the one that's showing. It could use a little bit more detail.
The shading and highlighting is really good. Accurate too. But the blood stand out a lot in some places, and doesn't look like PART of the character. But the gush and flow (Okay, that sounds weird.)is perfect. The blood on the grass could use some more shading though. But the fact that you added blood on the grass is already a pretty good point. Lots of people tend to forget that the blood doesn't just disappear.
Brambleclaw up at the front is really good too. And I love the way that he's a tad blurred. It makes Hawkfrost stick out more. All I can say is that his cheek fur doesn't seem balances. Like, one is bigger than the other. And I think he should be shaded a bit more, since he's deeper into the forest. (But that's just me.)
Anyway, all in all this a brilliant picture. Really, REALLY good. It's dramatic, and bold with a great balance of colors.
Well done e.deviantart.net/emoticons/s/sā¦ " width="15" height="15" alt="" title=" (Smile)"/> And I hope you found this critique helpfull!
š: 0 ā©: 1
MosaicSplash In reply to CerberusReigns [2010-05-15 01:11:29 +0000 UTC]
Thank you for the helpful critique!, but there are two things that I would like to know if you can:
What can I do to more detail the sand?
What is wrong with Hawkfrost's back leg?
THANK YOU MY CHILD FOR HELPIN ME OUT!
š: 0 ā©: 1
felidiva [2013-05-24 02:09:27 +0000 UTC]
Aww.
I liekd Hawkfrost.
Kinda. :3
š: 0 ā©: 0
redstarthunderclan [2012-12-01 23:18:08 +0000 UTC]
The background is AWESOME and I LOVE your Hawkfrost design
š: 0 ā©: 0
HawkFrost2 [2012-11-07 17:58:53 +0000 UTC]
WHAT? DO YOU HATE HAWKFROST OR SOMETHING?!
š: 0 ā©: 1
MosaicSplash In reply to HawkFrost2 [2012-11-11 23:54:52 +0000 UTC]
NOOOOOOO
IT'S JUST A PART OF THE BOOK!!
š: 0 ā©: 0
hellsxnt [2011-07-08 02:25:13 +0000 UTC]
I really like this!!
You did amazing!!
š: 0 ā©: 0
HellSpecterShadow222 [2011-04-19 14:58:48 +0000 UTC]
MosaicSplash if you can draw the death of Hawkfrost then where is the rest animation for Sunset that you SHOULD be working on.
š: 0 ā©: 1
MosaicSplash In reply to HellSpecterShadow222 [2011-04-20 01:52:10 +0000 UTC]
WELL, it is a lot LESS work to make one picture like this rather than to make a whole animation that takes me months. Plus I have a little bit of a life and this great fun thing called school and homework and this even BETTER thing called procrastination. It's pretty awesome B)
š: 0 ā©: 0
PrincessOfBabyGoats [2010-12-26 22:26:57 +0000 UTC]
i love this. poor Hawkfrost though. Even if he was crazy, he didnt deserve such a painful death
š: 0 ā©: 1
Cheshire-Crowy In reply to PrincessOfBabyGoats [2011-01-13 23:18:04 +0000 UTC]
He wasn't really crazy, just bended under Tigerstar's will.
Like father like son.
I don't believe Brambleclaw meant to kill Hawkfrost either. He doesn't seem like the type of cat to kill his own half-brother.
š: 0 ā©: 1
Slingshot24 [2010-12-03 00:18:30 +0000 UTC]
DUDE. THIS MAKES NO SENSE! WHY WOULD MY VOICE FOR ONE CAT END THE LIFE OF THE OTHER VOICE I DO??? IS MY VOICE TRYING TO LOSE WORK!?!??!
Its awesome, Though I have this strong feeling like if a throat was slit (and this is just me) that the head would have a tilt as if to acknowlege the difference. idk if you get what i mean... Like if my throat was cut i feel like i would look slightly down or lean forward because of the trauma, especially since the blood is flowing so quickly.
š: 0 ā©: 0
Icepath1995 [2010-05-15 19:15:08 +0000 UTC]
Wow this is good. Very interesting markings ^^
š: 0 ā©: 1
MosaicSplash In reply to Kittysh [2010-05-18 00:36:52 +0000 UTC]
thank you my british child
š: 0 ā©: 0
pmoth [2010-05-15 08:41:04 +0000 UTC]
I CAN HAS CRITIQUE?!
Okay so first the cats. The lineart for Hawkfrost looks a tiny bit sketchy when it comes to the fur, you might wanna erase the few extra random lines that stick out. Where his nech is bleeding, it would be a bit more realistic if he had some blood sputing from his neck, afterall he did have a main artery cut. Alos, the blood should be a bit darker in shade, it looks a bit flourecent. I really like how you did the shodow of the trees on the cats and the ground, it makes it looks more 3-dimensional. Personally, I hate it when people give warrior cats unrealistic makings, but thats just me. x3
ON TO THE BACKGROUND
I really love how you did the reflection of the sky on the water. Idk i just really love the lake.... I would've added more detail to the sand though, it looks just kinda flat like, the rest looks 3 dimensional, but the sand is just flat. You might want to take away those little stray leaves when using the leaf brush. You know, the ones that are just kinda floating in mid-air.Personally, I hate the leaf brush, It looks kindof funny to me....idk xD
But I do really like this picture. It really captures the emotion of the scene. GOOD JOB MAH GANGSTA PAL~
š: 0 ā©: 1
pmoth In reply to MosaicSplash [2010-05-15 16:16:26 +0000 UTC]
thsnk yew
š: 0 ā©: 0
BirdGirl89 [2010-05-15 02:31:43 +0000 UTC]
are those tigerstars whiskers behind hawkfrost??
š: 0 ā©: 1
MosaicSplash In reply to BirdGirl89 [2010-05-15 15:25:25 +0000 UTC]
no, Tigerstar is not in this picture at all.
š: 0 ā©: 0
MosaicSplash In reply to Yolly-anda [2010-05-15 00:24:39 +0000 UTC]
thanks, i worked hard on it and im glad it turned out nice ^^
š: 0 ā©: 0
alex5657123 [2010-05-15 00:06:34 +0000 UTC]
Nice job, the effects are really nice too, I love the shading C8
But.. whats up with the deigns? (I thought that was Thronclaw at first :U)
š: 0 ā©: 1
MosaicSplash In reply to alex5657123 [2010-05-15 00:08:16 +0000 UTC]
No, those are the character designs that I formed myself, idk what the hellz you be smokin X3
š: 0 ā©: 1
alex5657123 In reply to MosaicSplash [2010-05-15 00:09:34 +0000 UTC]
I iz not smoking anything D<
Its just, the designs look nothing like them so when I saw it was like "Wtf o-o"
š: 0 ā©: 1
MosaicSplash In reply to alex5657123 [2010-05-15 00:24:21 +0000 UTC]
um, I made the design of the cats, but i kept in mind the basic things about the cats.... personally I really like the designs of the Warrior cats that i use...
š: 0 ā©: 1