Comments: 6
Chopsticks-Pony [2015-10-05 21:50:35 +0000 UTC]
I decided to give this a closer look.
A lot of people didn't realize or forgot that the contest was exclusively focused on viewing angles, poses, and character interaction/body language and that the art style or even how good the art was is irrelevant to the judging criteria.
The only thing missing from your work is a bird's-eye-view (or 2), and difficult, better poses. You incorporated both humor and emotion in a (though overly long) story, some solid backgrounds, and you demonstrated pulling off working hard to achieve the goals you set yourself for. Your execution is a bit off and unusual, if incomplete, but your facial close-ups demonstrate what you're capable of at full capacity. It's perhaps easy to wave off your work from your execution (and Nsio wasn't looking for a comic, he was looking for a pose-practice set), but you approached the requirements and focus of the contest correctly.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Objurgo-Sol In reply to Chopsticks-Pony [2015-10-06 02:13:16 +0000 UTC]
Thanks ^_^
My direction could have used more work I agree, comics are a lot more difficult to pull off than I thought. But I like to think that my first try was decent, if somewhat unnecessary to this contest x]. I looked at it as practice contest, so I wanted to practice things that I was not used to doing, or wanted to test my ability in, this meant going further than just the poses Nsio had originally intended for us to do. Though I admit that the poses and direction are the weakest aspect of this practice :\
Thanks again, I always like to see analysis' and constructive criticism as opposed to my friends(and my own) nit picky nature lol
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
ColonelMarksman [2015-10-04 00:05:40 +0000 UTC]
I really like Sayaka's younger versions.
But dang, I think you could've gotten away with just the High School arc. But then I'm not sure if you saw that Nsio changed the rules a bit saying you only have to show how they became friends (not necessarily meet). I think that was supposed to make things easier, but it didn't for me!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Objurgo-Sol In reply to ColonelMarksman [2015-10-04 01:28:12 +0000 UTC]
Thanks ^_^
I get carried away with writing stories :[ I tried to hold back this time, I really did! Q_Q
👍: 0 ⏩: 0