Comments: 10
ChimeraDragonfang [2019-01-02 02:59:53 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
Back in summer of 2001 my family and I took a three-week road trip through Nova Scotia. One of the campgrounds where we overnighted had access to a rocky beach, and there were one or two large boulders farther out from the shore that you could walk to and possibly climb up when the tide was out, but would be nearly submerged when it was in. Anyway, the point of that seeming aside is that the opening paragraph put me in mind of that place, and I'm imagining her perched up on one of those rocks, gazing off into the bay as the Sun descends and the evening mist moves in.
I'm hoping my next few observations don't come across as too harsh. I seek only to help you level up your writing.
I get the feeling that you're maybe not quite clear on how to deploy semicolons, since all five in this piece should be commas instead (or they're just typos that snuck through). It's a simple enough test to see if a semicolon works: replace the semicolon with a fullstop, and if both the new sentences can stand alone as complete clauses, it's fine to use a semicolon. If one or the other isn't a complete clause by itself, then the semicolon should be a comma instead. (E.g. in the first paragraph, "It had been a beautiful day" can stand on its own, but "one of new experiences and old acquaintances" is a sentence fragment and cannot, so the semicolon should be a comma to properly bind them together. The same thing is happening at the other four places you've got a semicolon.)
"... shadows stretched from the boulder, wading in the water, with exhaustion from the day's excitement." The comma between "water" and "with", while not necessarily grammatically incorrect, breaks the flow for me. It reads a lot better after removing that comma entirely.
"The words had brought tears of joy and the sense of accomplishment, but the feelings have long since faded." That sudden present tense popping up in a piece that is written in past tense is a sudden stumbling block and I had to go back over it twice the first time I read this piece. That "have" feels better as a "had" to me. I would have probably written it as "words had once brought" and "but those feelings", but that's just me, and your approach isn't wrong.
"... knowing it did not belong to her, and she to it." With the negative "did not" in the first half, I would change that "and" to a "nor" for better flow.
The Sun "turning down its sheets" is such a cozy metaphor for sunset, and "spheres of rejection" is just so perfect a description for crumpled-up paper. Fits equally well for a rejection letter scrunched up in anger and to personal writing balled up because the writer felt it was trash and they knew they could do better. There are also a lot of great parallels between tearing out and throwing away pages of a book, and discarding bits of the past that no longer serve a purpose in living the present or plotting for the future.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ChimeraDragonfang In reply to PennedinWhite [2019-01-14 01:33:59 +0000 UTC]
Ha, damn, had I known it was an older one I might have skipped it in favour of something else. Feel kind of weird now for the grammar breakdown I gave since yeah, in 5+ years you've probably improved loads, but eh, there's always a chance that maybe someone else will glean some pointers from it.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
musica-nota [2019-03-20 01:30:57 +0000 UTC]
It really does feel like that when I look at my old writing
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
PennedinWhite In reply to IncognitoMallard [2013-08-09 22:52:07 +0000 UTC]
Thank you very much! I am glad you liked it.
And another thanks for the
👍: 0 ⏩: 1