Comments: 18
ActsofArt [2016-01-01 07:06:42 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
First of all, let me say how difficult this was to read and how I can't imagine going through something like that. I applaud your bravery for seeing this work through.
It somehow seems fitting to be reading this on the eve of the new year as it is a time many will be throwing away their inhibitions for the night.
As to the quality of this piece, I think that improving on the descriptive language would add more to the impact of this piece. Some of the wording seems simplistic which takes away from the depth of the piece and full immersion of the audience. Other parts have description that obscures rather than illuminates. To show you what I mean I will give examples below:
About this line: "but little did I know or particularly care at that intense moment." intense is a good word because it adds immediacy to the story. However it is unclear exactly why this moment is "intense." Is it intense because you have never drank before? or is it intense because the music is blaring and things are happening fast? More detail will help your reader understand the state of mind of the protagonist (you in this case).
This part: "Vulnerable to attack" a common mistake of all writers is wanting to reveal everything at once. Personally I would suggest waiting and building the moment up before revealing to the reader that there is any danger, you want the reader to connect with your character before revealing the central plot. If you want to hint at later events without revealing everything, I would suggest keeping this line: "I did not realize that they had evil brewing int their thoughts."
Which brings me neatly to descriptive language. This line is good but can be improved by better word choice such as: "I did not realize the dark thoughts lurking beneath their exterior expressions of good cheer." That may be too wordy but you can at least see how word choice enhances the feeling of the story.
I will also add that there is a good deal of "telling" going on when you really need to focus on showing readers what you mean. For instance at this part: "they were waiting for the right moment to strike..."
This is a form of telling the author what is going on, when it should say something that shows them such as: "They waited, biding their time as I slowly slipped from fully cognizant to barely conscious, as my mind disconnected from my body, leaving me calm and complacent. I was at their mercy, helpless, and they were out to destroy me." I am free writing here so it's not perfect but hopefully it gives you an idea of describing a scene rather than simply telling the audience about it. you want them in your shoes, feeling what you felt and seeing what you saw.
"things turned south" there are two issues with using this phrase. First and most obvious, it is a complete cliche and as such may put some readers off.
Secondly, you have already illuminated that things aren't what they seemed. You have established a sense of danger early on and as such, this line seems superfluous. It would be like saying "things are bad and suddenly they are going really bad." it's redundant.
I would suggest scrapping it and going with something along the lines of: "The atmosphere grew darker when..." or maybe "The night grew worse when..."
"the two of us girls..." this should have been established sooner rather than later. Unless you have some reason for waiting, but it really makes more since to introduce characters and how many at the beginning not in the middle. That interrupts flow and forces the reader to rethink the entire scene.
"My body was no longer mine, but his for the taking and I could do nothing to stop him." Watch those redundancies! You don't need the last part of that line the fact that your body is no longer yours means you can't do anything so this sentence can be halved: ""My body was no longer mine, but his for the taking."
"I barely felt it, never once flinching, but I knew something was not right. I was terrified."
This part seems out of place. earlier you described your body not knowing what was happening but now you do or at least know that something is wrong. Is this because you have become more lucid? what changed to make you comprehend the situation or part of it at least? Also, what exactly terrified you? be specific.
I think that covers most of what I thought could be fixed. I hope you don't think I was being too critical as I really like this piece and I dearly would love to see it in a more improved state. there are a lot of good qualities here that just need a little bit of enhancing to really bring the story into focus for the audience!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Eremitik [2017-03-05 12:45:30 +0000 UTC]
I cannot even begin to grasp how difficult this was for you to write. I am awed by your strength and bravery to expose your vulnerability like this.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
CutToTheSex [2016-05-22 15:51:33 +0000 UTC]
What a horrible experience. It's disgusting what people will do to others. This must have been hard to write about. I'm glad you had the strength to share your story and I hope you continue to move beyond it.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
themaninroomfive In reply to PennedinWhite [2016-01-10 15:08:19 +0000 UTC]
That's really great to hear ^^ I'm really happy for you and your family!!!
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
StrangelyShiny [2016-01-02 06:00:08 +0000 UTC]
A pretty good piece to put out around New Year's, I'd say. The idea of going in too deep and facing consequences as a result can be related to by many, and that really strengthens the poignancy of this story.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1