HOME | DD
qianying — FMA: Edwina Elric
Published: 2008-07-22 01:11:32 +0000 UTC; Views: 9991; Favourites: 200; Downloads: 328
Redirect to original
Description
Recently got another idea for doujins...
This time round may be quite ambitious!
I might attempt to "redraw" the original manga, with some changes....which is switching the gender for Ed and Winry! (if i change Ed only, it's no fun)
so the girl gets all the adventures! XD
and the boy works on automails, trying to make the best ones for the girl he waits for...
Btw, i wouldn't be changing Al's gender...
(he's in a suit or armour...)Currently i'm thinking that some scenarios may change as well due to the change in gender for Ed, for example in the fight with (previous)Greed, i think i'll change it to verbal battle rather than a real fight...(Greed says that he don't fight women) or something more, Ed gets kidnapped as well
(coz she's too cute! X3 )
Related content
Comments: 52
I really love this! Can I draw a colored version of it? I would give you credit.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Like the knew style. but to be honest, I think Ed would still have his/her clothing from the show.
But don't get me wrong this really good
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
I know this was done along time ago. And I never liked Gender bend but you pull it off very well 
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Oh yeah, are the hidden comments replies to me?
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
yeah, coz they are really long...
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
I hn;yt got a chance to read them. Could you display themso ican see. I am glad you can unrstand my messages. As well as being the world most earily pissed off eprson, i am make TONS of typos in writing. Thank godness for spelt and grammur check. ^_^
👍: 0 ⏩: 2
Ah now that i realised, those are all double posts from you...
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Yeah, sorryI can never really get eveerything said in one psot as i offen forget.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
oh sorry
I don't mind spelling errors as long as i can understand them, just that i will correct any spelling mistakes almost automatically whenever i type so typos may be rare for me. *is perfectinist in some way*
👍: 0 ⏩: 2
BTW, i did not realise they were double posts. Sorry.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
You think your a perfectionist? I am a personionst. Eeryone my bedroom and other plaves had a cerntain place and everythng has be perfectly clean and tidy. I sometiimes think i have OCD, but i don't know. I took after my mum the tidyig sense XD.
Meanwhile, my brother is your typcial boy. You know where hes been as they is a trail of meempty crisps packets, stray DVDs, anything really, behind him. Sometimes he even messes up my bedroom because he konws how much i hate mess. Do you have any siblings?
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
I will nitpick on some things, but not everything. Like, my room can be a little messy but i will never let it go too horribly messy *looks at my pile of unfolded clothes...*
I do have an older sister, but somehow she is a little messier with her room, notes and files all scattered around the floor of her room, i don't feel like doing the vacuum cleaning for her room seriously
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
I laways make sure my clothes are put away. They have specipic places in my chest of drawers. My mum takes care of the washing though.
Ah so your the younger one. I am the oldest, only a 1 year seperates me and my brother. I wish i had a sister.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Oh, forgot to say, if you were wondering with a Gender Bended Pride. Well, i just thought that after Lust died we needed more female Humunculi. I wan the the First Anime we had Sloth so...And i could not imagine the others as female, (wel Second!Greed might be female since he/she would be pocessing a girl).
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Fem!Ed (Edwina Elric. Hate being called short by people. Even more hate Roya or Winter making fun of her small breasts.)
Fem!Al (Alphonsa Elric. Sometimes get mistaken for a boy by children until told otherwise.)
Male!Winry (Winter Rockbell.)
Fem!Roy (Roya Mustang. She makes fun of Edwina’s breasts, telling her she “is not a woman with a her near-flat chest“)
Male!Riza (Rizo Hawkeye. He is a bit more protective then original!Riza. Havoc has a bit of crush on her, which will be made apparent in the fight between them and Lust)
Ling Yao (No name change as “Ling” can be male or female)
Ran Fan (I like the name as it is)
Meo Chan (cute little prince from Xing. Some people think he is too young to have feeling such as love J)
Selima Bradley (cute, lively daughter of the Führer. A kind, sweet little girl who wants to be simply be called “Selima” instead of “Lady Selima” or “Mistress”. Secretly a blood-thirsty homunculus). I felt the manga needed more female homunculus.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
For my fanfic it will be:
Fem!Ed (Edwina Elric. Getts annoyed went people call her short, or Roya makes fun of her small brests, tell ing her "she is not woman but a girl until they are big as hers")
Fem!Al (Alphonsa Elric. Sometimes get mistaken for a boy by children until told otherwise.)
Male!Winry (Winter Rockbell.)
Fem!Roy (Roya Mustang)
Male!Riza (Rizo Hawkeye. He is a bit more protective then original!Riza. Havoc has a bit of crush on her, which will be made apparent in the fight between them and Lust)
Ling Yao (No name change as “Ling” can be male or female)
Ran Fan (I like the name as it is)
Meo Chan (cute little prince obsessed with a certain girl. Some people think he is too young to have such feelings J)
Selima Bradley (cute, lively daughter of the Führer. A kind, sweet little girl who wants to be simply be called “Selima” instead of “Lady Selima” or “Mistress”. Secretly a blood-thirsty homunculus).
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
For my fanfic it will be:
Fem!Ed (Edwina Elric. Getts annoyed went people call her short, or Roya makes fun of her small brests, tell ing her "she is not woman but a girl until they are big as hers")
Fem!Al (Alphonsa Elric. Sometimes get mistaken for a boy by children until told otherwise.)
Male!Winry (Winter Rockbell.)
Fem!Roy (Roya Mustang)
Male!Riza (Rizo Hawkeye. He is a bit more protective then original!Riza. Havoc has a bit of crush on her, which will be made apparent in the fight between them and Lust)
Ling Yao (No name change as “Ling” can be male or female)
Ran Fan (I like the name as it is)
Meo Chan (cute little prince obsessed with a certain girl. Some people think he is too young to have such feelings J)
Selima Bradley (cute, lively daughter of the Führer. A kind, sweet little girl who wants to be simply be called “Selima” instead of “Lady Selima” or “Mistress”. Secretly a blood-thirsty homunculus).
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Oh i forgot Super Heroiens in things like marvel. They are partiually guilty of the "woman wearing revealing/skin-tight clothing)
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Oh i forgot Super Heroiens in things like marvel. They are partiually guilty of the "woman wearing revealing/skin-tight clothing)
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
I saw this aaaages ago and forgot to add to my "FMA Gender Bender" collection, so i have now.
BTW, i have to say in the doujinshi, will Ed always be wearing so little (i am just saying because original!Ed always wore long clothes to conceal his automail. Also I don‘t like girls in anime/manga (and real life) always wearing revealing clothes, e.g. Winry, Revi (Black Lagoon), Sailor Senshi (Sailor Moon), Yoko Littner (Gurren Lagann) Laura Croft (Tomb Raider), evey woman in “James Bond” and countless others.
You are you favourite Gender Bender FMA Artist, as you draw the characters of almost exactly the way i would imagine them as the opposite gender. (Only difference would be my Fem!Ed (i called her Edwina too, but not because of you, its just well, its the best name that begins with "Ed". I don't know why other people make it "Edna" or "Edaline") had her all the way to her hips, and my Fem!Roy, Roya, has the same fringe as Roy, but the same as you fem with the rest of the hair, and well big breasts, as well , she would be a man-eater ^_^) Finally my Male!Mei (Meo) has his hair in a single bun (kind of like Ran Fan) on the back of his head. Ok i have ranted on usual. Great picture anyway ^_^
I am gender bending both the anime and the manga, i was original doing First 2003 Anime, but the lure of the manga has became too much, so i will be switching the manga storey after i finish latest chapter of anime one.
BTW, does you Winter call Edwina “Ed”?
Mine calls Edwina and Alphonsa (originally “Alice” which is better?) “Ed” and “Al” because Edwina is such a tomboy and for Alphonsa its because it its “cute” and he think Alphonsa is cute (well, before her soul was sealing in armour and original!Al is adorable too, every time I see young!Al I want to hug him and Ed too).
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Bahahahaha... Edwina Elric. xD
That'd be so weird if Ed was a girl... 0.o
But damn, you made her look hot! *thumbs up*
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Awww she is SO cute! I like that you made her hair longer. I also like that you didn't just slap boobs on Ed and called it a day. There are actually differences in the face and the eyes so that's a big help. I think she might be a touch more self conscious about her auto-mail even more so than her male counterpart. But I understand that you wanted to showcase the fact that she's a girl.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Thank you~ XD
I can't possibly draw that manly or boyish face, with boobs and call 'that' a girl...(that'll make ppl including myself puke >< )
Anyway...she might actually feel that having automail is cool and so wears shorts sometimes(to show-off?)...
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Maybe, but I think if she's going for shock factor than it's easier to hide it and then when it's revealed people can go "OMGWTFBBQ!!"
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
'M wondering... will you make Rose a guy then? xD;
That's be HILARIOUS.
And then "Winter" and "Roosevelt" (meaning field of roses) can fight over Edwina like some shoujo manga. xD;;;
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Nope
It's too tiring and difficult to change too many ppl's gender...this might cause drastic change in their roles somehow and even the story...
But i will make quite a number of guys to fight over Ed XDDDD (eg male!Winry, Ling, Roy, Envy, Greed...etc)
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
I like the alterations to the outfit. My only qualms are with the shorts. I mean, maybe girl!Ed is different, but I just feel like if girl!Ed wore shorts it would take away from the mystery of her limbs. You know? Like, part of Ed's thing is that he doesn't reveal that he has metal limbs until absolutely necessary. But that's just me. (Plus that way you don't have to always draw the automail leg all the time.)
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Yeah, the she will usually wear long pants like in original manga...
But i juz feel like drawing her in shorts and some sexy outfit to show that it's really a girl!Ed X3
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
It's cool. I just wanted to put my two cents in. ^^
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
That's exactly how I picture lady!Ed. Marvelous. <3 I love the idea, too.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
wow........i didnt know ed could look so hot.......
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
I like the concept of the male waiting, you dont see that often
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Haha yup, but maybe i'll want to add in more action for male!Win XD
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
XD Thats awesome! it almost kinda looks like my FMA character! >W< But shes kinda like a female version of Ed anyway.... a twin sister... ^-^
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Well her design sure rocks. Hahah, Ed as a woman?? sounds so cool
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Actually her design was inspired from the Tomb Raider Lara XD
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
I see... Yeah, there's some resemblance. Nice!
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
| Next =>