Comments: 30
modesty [2005-06-15 22:13:00 +0000 UTC]
Argh...the comment box is WAAAAY down here and the picture is waaaay up there. GRAR! But because Ikeda is so nice to me and tears my pieces to shreds before brutally beating down on me with the remains of the Shredmaster2000, I'll offer my opinions. And good humor.
First...ZOMG! What's that in his pants!?? Random floaty article of clothing I suppose...I guess I stuff the underwear I steal in my back pockets too. :b0x0rs: Joke!
really, first off, the detail on your sketches is always amazing and so refined looking. You even go in and SHADE before anything. (I just skip to the inking and shade later XD) According to other critiques, most of the body points have already been covered to an extent. So, I'm going to attack the wings. ^_^
They don't look like natural wings, even for an angel. The wings are missing a joint. (KInd of like an arm without an elbow) Generally speaking, even in most anime, the wings tend to keep the anatomy of a birds wing. You can actually pose a wing by looking at your own arm. Your shoulder is where the wing connects to the body, theres a bend in the elbow, and your wrist is the other joint. Your fingers are like the flight feathers. Umm...if that's unclear think of a bat wing. It looks like a hand too.
[link] <---Here's a better explanation. It will help them look more like wings that will hold him up.
That's all for now.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Aku-Rei [2005-06-15 21:13:28 +0000 UTC]
all right, i will "play" with the quality tonight so if i get it to work right i will send it to you tomorrow, if not then i will try to send it by at least friday.
oh and glad i could be of help.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Aku-Rei [2005-06-15 13:38:35 +0000 UTC]
hmm. Nathanael
derived from the hebrew name Nethane'el, which ment "God has given", Nathanael isn't really derived from Nathan nor Nathan from Nathanael, it is more like they share a common link with the hebrew word for gift or given or something like that.
(i have a stupid hobby of finding the meaning behind names plus my youngest brother is named Nathanael)
****the critique**** well a quick critique (chem in 9 minutes an i got a good 12 min walk)
i can tell this isn't to the same level of completion as a lot of your other sketches so i won't say much, just what stands out.
the waist could stand to be a little larger, and i know the long slender legs thing is more your style but they are slightly thinner then you usually do them.
the wings look a little rushed, but nothing too bad.
****Hikari no will power****
Hey i have that song on a mix cd somewhere. mine was downloaded a while back, before people started getting sued. and it sounds like a live recording from a concert or something. i don't know the kbps off hand but i do know i can up the quality. (got to love Soundtrack and iTunes)
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ikeda In reply to Aku-Rei [2005-06-15 17:22:41 +0000 UTC]
I'm gonna reply to the Hikari no Will Power thing first because uh... because I can't help it: Send it to me Send it to me! SEND IT TO ME PLEASE! Ok, well, that's done (If it's 128kbps or more, it's all good!!)
I never knew Nethane'el, I just liked Nathan and added something to it. It made me think of Alexiel from Angel Sanctuary... Alex+-iel=Alexiel! I'm so smart!!! Ok, whatever XD Y'know.. you can help me come up with OC names!!! Oh my God!
Ok, more seriously now... Yes, it's much less complex than most other things I've done. Glad you noticed It was basically a quickie to get the design out, nothing more. Other than having problems with legs, I have problems with larger waists, so yes, I'll try to work on it >_> or slack off, time will tell.
About the thinness of the legs, I'm heading for an even skinnier look! Ugh, we'll see how it ends up.
Ah, the wings were rushed. That's why they're so ugly and goofy. I don't usually do anything like this for stuff I'm serious about though, so no worries. I'm not sacrificing quality!
Thanks for the crit and info!
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
hodengai [2005-06-15 04:48:07 +0000 UTC]
Cool and dynamic.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Ransouu [2005-06-15 04:28:14 +0000 UTC]
The only problem that I can find is...The legs. It's the left leg...It could use more shape. In my opinion.
It's really nice. Better than anything i could ever draw! ^^
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ikeda In reply to amade [2005-06-15 17:12:34 +0000 UTC]
Actually, I left that note on the concept for Lilith image as well I guess you missed it.
For the general body, I'm heading for a really thin structure, which explains that the legs look a bit like cylinders. Think of Kazuki Takahashi (Yu-Gi-Oh)or CLAMP's (later volumes of X) styles, which have inspired me a lot. Although their style isn't realistic, it's the way they view the human body.
To make up for the lack of curviness in the legs, I can only say that he's not that muscular and that his pants don't stick to his body. Despite the excuses, I'll keep in mind what you said.
Actually, I've seen a few guys who have their hands dangling at mid(or third of)-thigh. I remember that well because I was really happy that not all guys had arms as long as my 9th grade French teacher (his only went below the crotch like you mentionned). It really depends on how people are shaped. Some people have a long upper body, and others have long lower bodies. My hands reach the middle of my thighs, but other girls have hands that only go beneath their buttocks (because uh.. they have large buttocks).
I agree with the hands. I had originally darkened the finger lines, but I guess they got smudged in the process.
All of his body is slightly turned towards the viewer's left actually. I don't quite understand what you mean about the shoulder and hip width. For guys, the the shoulders are suppose to be larger than the hips o_O
The wings I slacked off on, so you can blame me for those all day Since this was simply a concept sketch, I was only looking to create this character's general look. I didn't pay too much attention to the wings because they're long to draw. But, you know I work harder on them in normal circumstances, right?
I don't mind the harshness, but just keep in mind that the serie of pencil drawings I'm doing right now are all meant for character creation and design, which means I'll put less effort into them than into my real projects!
Oh, and the guide is only meant to be used for tips and help to critiquing. Give me feedback on it when you're done with it.
By the way, I think that separating your critique into paragraphs would make it easier to read through. Although it can work as it is, I think that dividing it would make it easier to read since for some things you present quite a long point.
Thanks for the crit!
👍: 0 ⏩: 2
amade In reply to ikeda [2005-06-16 04:17:26 +0000 UTC]
You're welcome. Elastigirl's obvious dispropotionateness is an example of how you can exaggerate certain features and make em' look good. Some may find it freaky while some may perceive it to look (almost) natural.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Yue-Xumeragi In reply to ikeda [2005-06-15 17:48:03 +0000 UTC]
I'm not spamming, it just sounded like it was going to look so rude if noted! I needed a window, and found it here. ¬_¬;;
I also had planned to critic later in this same tread XD sorry
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
SummonOfCloud [2005-06-15 00:47:18 +0000 UTC]
hey, I really like your faces and hair you put in good highlights in that make the hair look 3D. But something looks wierd to me with his arms and legs. It kinda looks like his right arm is thicker than his left but since its further back should be just a lil smaller than the forground. It also looks like his arm pit is started a lil high (left arm) I know he has his shoulders shruged so maybe im wrong. and his legs are a lil long and maybe angled wierd. by the way his name is good since an archangel's name always end in el. does the ball glow?
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
SummonOfCloud In reply to SummonOfCloud [2005-06-15 19:08:07 +0000 UTC]
...I spelt bright wrong....and some other stuff.....wish I would see it before I click on the "submit" button.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
dragonofsarrow [2005-06-14 23:30:48 +0000 UTC]
Well you wanted some critique so.... I think most of the body proportions are very good, however the legs seem a little long. Other than that I think it's a really great pic and.... what's that thing attached to his waist? It's sorta hard to see what it is.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Reb320 [2005-06-14 23:26:57 +0000 UTC]
looks good!
👍: 0 ⏩: 0