Comments: 11
saturdaystorytellers [2018-02-11 22:29:39 +0000 UTC]
Overall
Vision
Originality
Technique
Impact
So I take this to be your genuine life story. With that in mind, it's a little harder than normal to judge it for vision, originality and impact, but I'll do my best anyway.
It's hard to know what details you've missed out with this story because, of course, only you would know those, but I'd say that if you want to present your life story for entertainment purposes, you may wish to round out your descriptions of some parts of your life to help boost their impact in the final, finished story, and perhaps change some of the timings of the story to help the whole story hang together better.
As far as originality goes, you're not the first person to tell your life story and I daresay you wont' be the last, so in that sense, this isn't very original. However, your life story is uniquely yours so in that sense it is.
It looks like you've taken the advice of a previous reviewer and cut this story into smaller paragraphs, so it was easier to read than a text wall. I'd say that you need to enlist a beta-reader to point out several words that you've missed. It's usually clear enough what you mean in these sentences, but you have missed out quite a few words here and there. Other than that, if you're willing, you may want to help boost the impact of some of what you write as part of your life story so that your readers feel the story more. It comes across as a description of events rather than an emotive piece, and for me, that distanced me from what I read here. That may simpy be your style, however, so I'll leave it up to you to decide whether you want to 'flower it up' for the sake of entertainment.
And as far as impact goes - certainly this story impacted me because it actually happened. Mental illnesses can be very difficult to manage, and you have managed to make the best of a life that has often been tough. Good on you!
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
mininessie In reply to crazydave11 [2017-12-30 17:04:45 +0000 UTC]
I know grammar is poor it’s probably due to my mental illnesses and I struggle with it since the way I write I write first punctuate last and I know that’s not the way it should be done and I want to correct it but I feel that since the way I write I think makes grammar not make sense to me in terms of improving it if you or anyone know where I can help on this I’d appreciate it cause I love to write and I’m kind of good at it just need grammar overhaul I never thought about it but yeah I could slow it down since it turned more into a biography but it was long enough already in my mind but for the project it was which was a recovery story it was long enough but to explain everything it had to happen that way
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
benlonewolf93 [2017-12-30 09:56:34 +0000 UTC]
one time, in Wilson High School, i saw a student whose name i can't remember (I'm not good with most names, TBH) get sent to the Principal's office, twice, for being insubordinate. that's one mistake i won't make. that shows i can learn from the mistakes of others. not just my own. Anyways, hope you have a great life, man.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Riemea [2017-12-29 18:45:47 +0000 UTC]
Since I saw on your profile that your main concern with this story is grammar I'm going to focus on that instead of anything else. It can be difficult for oneself to spot errors (be it spelling, grammar, or something else), but what always helps me is to read the text out loud. If something doesn't sound quite right to your own ears there is a high chance that it is not quite right.
One thing I noticed a lot is the way you connect sentences and use punctuation. You almost never use subordinate clauses, instead you mostly just write one main clause after another, seperated by periods. A lot of the time you cut sentences short that way, which makes your story a bit hard to read and understand. For example in the first line:
To tell you the story of my recovery. I'd have to go back and tell you how that for most of my life I wasn't even diagnosed. or here: Meaning that in my imaginary world. I live in Boston where I have a wife and a daughter.
Leaving out the period between those two sentences makes it much easier to read, and also makes more sense to the reader.
A lot of your problems with grammar in your story are a result from your use (or lack of use) of punctuation. I still have trouble with punctuation myself, so I don't think I'm qualified to tell you where you're going wrong, I just know that you need to be careful with where you use periods and commas and where you don't.
You also have to be careful not to mix up tenses:
What makes this unique was the fact that it may or may not have consumed my life.
You're talking about things in the present so every verb in this sentence needs to be in the present: What makes this unique was is the fact that it may or may not have consumed be consuming my life.
Another example (this time everything needs to be in the past instead of the present): Probably because I sleep for nearly a day which I probably needed more than anything. --> Probably because I sleep slept for nearly a day which I probably needed more than anything.
If I had the time I would offer to go through the story line by line, but as it is I can only give you an overview of what to look out for. If you want to get more in-depth feedback I suggest maybe finding an editor, although you'd probably have to pay them. On the other hand you'd have a professional going through your story.
If you want to receive more feedback from people on DeviantArt, may I suggest joining ProjectComment ? It's a great group for people who want to give and receive feedback.
In any case, don't give up! You are going to find more people who are willing to help you with improving your writing. I hope I was able to help at least a bit. If you want me to clarify anything/have questions about anything I mentioned above don't hesitate to ask!
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
mininessie In reply to Jack-the-Shinigami [2017-10-19 23:20:46 +0000 UTC]
Thanks I’m not use to the way DeviantArt handles things when you copy and paste lol
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
celticbard76 [2015-08-29 16:52:24 +0000 UTC]
I was quite stunned reading your final paragraph. I also have GP, a severe case (takes me eight hours to empty my stomach, even on those stupid prokinetics they give us) and I have been writing about it on DA, partly as a form of therapy, but also because I'm trying desperately to get back into writing after suffering from a two year GP-induced writer's block. Reading your piece was very touching, although I'm so sorry to hear that you are going through this mess of an illness too. If you would ever like to chat about GP or writing or anything else, please feel free to contact me. I always love hearing from others who are going through this struggle. And I have to say, I'm curious as to how you managed to get on social security. I heard that it was nearly impossible for GPers.
Anyhow, your story was beautiful, so honest and, at times, heart-wrenching. I wish you all the best and hope you have success in living with GP. And thanks for posting this piece. I know it must have taken a great deal of courage.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Seraphina16 In reply to celticbard76 [2017-12-30 11:57:55 +0000 UTC]
What is GP? I know that where I live it stands for General Practitioner, but I've ever heard of it as a condition.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0